# Cum-Cum, Cartels and Compliance: Where German Review Volume Comes From in 2026

_2026-11-18_

German review teams are rarely short of documents, even though much of their work never passes through a civil court. As we described in [our story on where German document work comes from](/stories/ediscovery-in-germany-without-discovery-where-the-document-work-comes-from), it tends to arrive through a prosecutor's warrant, a competition authority's inspection or a report that a compliance team has to follow up. Two events this year show what that work can look like in practice, and why so much of it concerns records that are many years old.

On July 22, 2026, prosecutors searched Deutsche Bank's Frankfurt headquarters over Cum-Cum transactions that Postbank is suspected of having made between 2008 and 2010. A few weeks earlier, on June 30, 2026, the Bundeskartellamt presented its annual report for 2025/26, with its account of the tip-offs, searches and fines behind its cartel work.

This story reads both for what they mean to the people who run document review, and then shows where Claira, working inside Nuix Discover, fits into a review of that kind.

## A tax search about transactions from 2008

As [ZDF reported](https://www.zdfheute.de/wirtschaft/unternehmen/deutsche-bank-postbank-durchsuchung-steuerhinterziehung-100.html), the Staatsanwaltschaft Düsseldorf carried out the search on July 22, 2026, in an investigation of suspected tax evasion through Cum-Cum transactions at Postbank between 2008 and 2010. According to ZDF, ten former Postbank managers are suspects, the allegation concerns false or incomplete corporate tax returns, and investigators put the tax loss at more than 350 million euros. Deutsche Bank, the legal successor to Postbank, confirmed the measure and said it would cooperate fully.

[onvista's report](https://www.onvista.de/news/2026/07-22-deutsche-bank-durchsucht-verdacht-um-geschaefte-der-postbank-0-20-26534824) adds that Postbank premises in Bonn were searched as well, and that the bank described itself as affected only as a third party, since the transactions took place before Postbank was wholly owned by Deutsche Bank. In the transactions as onvista describes them, foreign investors passed their shares to German banks or funds shortly before the dividend date to take advantage of a difference in tax treatment, then took them back afterwards with part of the dividend as compensation.

The tax questions belong to the specialists. For a review team, the striking feature is the date range: the conduct under investigation dates from 2008 to 2010, and the search took place in 2026. German law makes room for long investigations. Under [§ 376(1) of the Abgabenordnung](https://dejure.org/gesetze/AO/376.html), the limitation period for prosecution is 15 years in the cases of particularly serious tax evasion listed in § 370(3), sentence 2, numbers 1 to 6. Which provisions apply to a particular investigation is a matter for the prosecutors, the courts and defence counsel. The practical consequence for review is simpler: a tax matter can reach back much further than the document sets most teams handle in a typical year.

## What a record set from 2008 looks like

Documents of that age bring their own problems, and adding reviewers solves few of them. In the Postbank case, ownership changed over the period: [ZDF notes](https://www.zdfheute.de/wirtschaft/unternehmen/deutsche-bank-postbank-durchsuchung-steuerhinterziehung-100.html) that Deutsche Bank acquired Postbank between 2008 and 2018. Integrations of that kind often mean migrated mail systems, archived file shares and records exported from applications that no longer run.

The people change too. Custodians from the period may have left years ago, desks and teams have been renamed, and the internal shorthand of the time (product names, deal labels, abbreviations) may mean nothing to the reviewers who read it today. A keyword list written from the present vocabulary of the business can miss the documents that matter most, because the people who wrote them used different words.

A set like this also tends to mix German and English, and to include scanned paper alongside email. Each of these affects what a review can do before anyone reads a document, and each is worth knowing about at the start rather than halfway through.

## The Bundeskartellamt's year in figures

The cartel side of German review work is visible in the Bundeskartellamt's [press release on its annual report](https://www.bundeskartellamt.de/SharedDocs/Meldung/DE/Pressemitteilungen/2026/06_30_2026_Jahresbericht.html), published on June 30, 2026. In 2025 the authority received 815 tip-offs about possible infringements of competition law. It carried out four search operations in its own proceedings and six more by way of administrative assistance, among them searches for the European Commission. It collected around 18 million euros in fines over the year. Its president, Andreas Mundt, called the detection and prosecution of cartels a core task of the authority.

Those figures trace the start of cartel document work: a tip-off, a search and a company that needs to understand the seized material and its own records before it answers the authority. The press release gives no document counts for the proceedings, so the size of any one matter has to come from the matter itself.

The same pressure falls on compliance teams. A company that learns of a possible infringement, whether through its own reporting channel or through an authority's inspection, usually needs an internal investigation, and that investigation reads the same mailboxes and file shares the authority is interested in. Cartel conduct, like tax conduct, can run for years before anyone looks at it, so the review set often spans a long period and many custodians.

## Where Claira fits in a long review

Claira runs inside Nuix Discover, so the review happens in the platform where the data is already hosted, and answers are written to fields on the documents. For a German matter, Claira can keep a case's data in the EU. A few features matter most when the set reaches back many years.

The first is [Case Context](https://support.claira.to/docs/en/case-context/overview), a structured briefing on the matter that Claira draws on when it generates prompts. Depending on the template, it can hold the parties and key players, the background and timeline, the issues and the privilege and confidentiality rules. For an old record set, this is where the team writes down the entities, people and period vocabulary that today's reviewers would not know. A context is visible to everyone on the case, so privileged strategy stays out of it, and Prompt History records which version of which context each prompt was built from.

The second is the order of work the help centre recommends:

1. Test a prompt on a sample of 10 to 25 documents.
2. Revise it until the answers match what counsel expects.
3. Run it across the set as a [bulk scan](https://support.claira.to/docs/en/ai-review/bulk-scan), which takes up to 999,999 documents per task and writes results to the connected Nuix Discover field while the task is still running.

The third is the date work that a decade-spanning matter depends on. The [Chronologies workflow](https://support.claira.to/docs/en/workflows/chronologies) reduces each document to one dated sentence in a sortable format and flags documents without an identifiable date. Insights can then condense the results of a bulk task into a chronology or an investigation narrative, with citations linking each claim to its source document. Claira checks that every citation names a document the Insight read, though it does not yet check that the document supports the claim, so a reviewer still reads the sources.

For mixed-language sets, the Translation workflow identifies a document's language and writes an English summary, which can help where counsel or a parent company works in English. The help centre is clear that these summaries do not replace professional translation for documents that matter to a production. Early case assessment gives overview statistics from the case's metadata without scanning document content, which is a reasonable first look at an inherited set. Text scans need extracted text, and a document without it returns an error; for scanned paper, Claira's media scans can read image files such as PDFs.

## Planning for the next request

The Postbank search and the Bundeskartellamt's figures point the same way: German review work often arrives on short notice and concerns records that predate the current team. Teams that already know the location and condition of their older data, and the colleagues who can explain it, are better placed when a warrant or an inspection arrives.

Nothing here is legal advice on any matter. If you would like to see how Case Context, bulk scan and the Chronologies workflow handle an older record set, you can [book a session with our team](/meet) and try them on your own documents.